ameri resources


Need an office in metro Detroit, Alabama or Toronto? Office suites, meeting rooms, virtual offices, network access




free downloads
USA: "U.S. taxation of foreign citizens (2016)" report

USA: "U.S. taxation of foreign citizens (2016)" report. 63-page report by KPMG.

proceed to download
eJournals





back to index backAMERItalk September,  2016


NAFTA’s Impact on the U.S. Economy: What Are the Facts?

When President Bill Clinton signed the North American Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in December 1993, he predicted that NAFTA will tear down trade barriers between our three nations, create the world’s largest trade zone, and create 200,000 jobs in [the U.S.] by 1995 alone. The environmental and labor side agreements negotiated by our administration will make this agreement a force for social progress as well as economic growth.” Twenty-three years later, scholars and policy makers often disagree about the impact that NAFTA has had on economic growth and job generation in the U.S. That impact, they say, is not always easy to disentangle from other economic, social and political factors that have influenced U.S. growth.

On the positive side, overall trade between the three NAFTA partners — the U.S., Canada and Mexico — has increased sharply over the pact’s history, from roughly $290 billion in 1993 to more than $1.1 trillion in 2016. Cross-border investment has also surged during those years, as the stock of U.S. foreign direct investment (FDI) in Mexico rose from $15 billion to more than $107.8 billion in 2014. As for job growth, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, six million U.S. jobs depend on U.S. trade with Mexico, a flow that has been greatly facilitated by NAFTA, which has helped eliminate costly tariff and non-tariff barriers. NAFTA has also facilitated a multi-layered integration of the U.S., Mexican and Canadian supply chains. According to the Wilson Center, twenty-five cents out of every dollar of goods that are imported from Canada to the U.S. is actually Made in USA” content, as are 40 cents out of every dollar for goods imported into the U.S. from Mexico.

Geronimo Gutierrez, managing director of the North American Development Bank (NADB), notes that trade between the United States and Mexico reached over $500 billion in 2015, a five-fold increase since 1992, when NAFTA negotiations concluded. Thus, he explains, Mexico imports more from the U.S. these days than do all of the so-called BRIC nations combined – Brazil, Russia, India and China. (The NADB acts as a binational catalyst in helping communities along the U.S.-Mexico border develop affordable, long-term infrastructure.)

Gutierrez adds that there are lesser-known benefits of NAFTA. By promoting the tight integration of North American industrial supply chains, NAFTA is creating partners and not competitors among its member countries. As for Mexico’s interest in this bilateral relationship, it can be summarized in two facts: about 80% of Mexico’s exports go to the U.S., while 50% of the accumulated foreign direct investment received between 2000 and 2011 comes from the U.S. Moreover, NAFTA has been the fundamental anchor for reforms that make Mexico a more modern economy and open society.”

A Modest Impact

For all that, most studies conclude that NAFTA has had only a modest positive impact on U.S. GDP. For example, according to a 2014 report by the Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE), the United States has been $127 billion richer each year thanks to extra” trade growth fostered by NAFTA. For the United States, with its population of 320 million at the time of that study, the pure economic payoff was thus only $400 per person, while per capita GDP was close to $50,000. And while the costs of NAFTA are highly concentrated in specific industries like auto manufacturing — where job losses may be significant for specific firms — the benefits of the trade pact (such as lower prices for imported electronics or clothing) are distributed widely across the U.S., as they are in the case of any trade pact worldwide.

Most studies conclude that NAFTA has had only a modest positive impact on U.S. GDP.

Supporters of NAFTA estimate that some 14 million jobs rely on trade with Canada and Mexico combined, and the nearly 200,000 export-related jobs created annually by NAFTA pay an average salary of 15% to 20% more than the jobs that were lost, according to a PIIE study. Furthermore, the study found that only about 15,000 jobs on net are lost each year due to NAFTA. On our reckoning, since NAFTA’s enactment, fewer than 5% of U.S. workers who have lost jobs from sizable layoffs (such as when large plants close down) can be attributed to rising imports from Mexico,” wrote its authors, PIIE senior fellow Gary Clyde Hufbauer and research analyst Cathleen Cimino-Isaacs. For the roughly 200,000 out of 4 million people who lose their jobs annually under these circumstances, the job losses can be attributed to rising imports from Mexico, they wrote, but almost the same number of new jobs has been created annually by rising U.S. exports to Mexico.” Moreover, For every net job lost in this definition, the gains to the U.S. economy were about $450,000, owing to enhanced productivity of the workforce, a broader range of goods and services, and lower prices at the checkout counter for households.”

Trade specialists agree that it has proven difficult to separate the deal’s direct effects on trade and investment from other factors, including rapid improvements in technology, expanded trade with other countries such as China and unrelated domestic developments in each of the countries.

Source: Knowledge @ Wharton - GAI






previous page

go top
search our site


Loading

AMERItalk

Other articles from the same issue (September,  2016).

The Growing Role of Mexico in the North American Automotive Industry - Trends, Drivers and Forecasts
play read on

The Auto Industry’s Real Challenge
play read on

Autos: North America Build Reflects Stable Environment (download report)
play read on

Key facts about Canada's automotive industry
play read on

Federal Automated Vehicles Policy: 6 Key Issues for the Automotive Supply Chain
play read on

The Potential Effects of the 2017-2025 EPA/NHTSA GHG/Fuel Economy Mandates on the U.S. Economy
play read on

GM auto workers in Canada OK new contract
play read on

Sorry China, the future of next-generation manufacturing is in the US
play read on

NAFTA’s Impact on the U.S. Economy: What Are the Facts?
play read on

Manufacturers Challenge Overtime Rule
play read on

The Aggregate Economic Cost of New Labor Market Regulations
play read on

U.S. Companies Turn to German Training Model to Fill Jobs Gap
play read on

Don’t Blame A ‘Skills Gap’ For Lack Of Hiring In Manufacturing
play read on

Robots will eliminate 6% of all US jobs by 2021, report says
play read on

Ten Mistakes U.S. Businesses Make When Shipping To Canada
play read on

America’s Promise to Fund Manufacturing Education
play read on

Sourcing multi-year compensation, stock options, for foreign tax credit limitation
play read on

Canada: Are employers responsible for protecting their employees on social media? "Yes" according to a recent decision
play read on

Brexit: What now for US companies?
play read on

How to Bring Back Manufacturing Jobs
play read on

Ontario, Canada: Perception vs. Reality
play read on

Toronto is poised to become the next great producer of tech startups
play read on

Employment-at-Will Versus the Discharge-for-Just-Cause-Only Standard: A Critical Employment Law Distinction
play read on

EEOC Issues New Guidance on Retaliation
play read on

U.S.: Expatriate taxation - Don't be a cowboy!
play read on

Canada: Expected shorter wait-period for certain government benefits might affect employer plans
play read on

Bird's Eye View: Comparing Chinese Investment into North America and Europe
play read on

Labor Day Origins: Examining US And Canada Labor Laws
play read on

Notice 2016-52: Foreign tax credit related to foreign-initiated adjustments
play read on

How to move abroad: Practical advice for anxious Americans
play read on

U.S. Cities Slipping in Race for Global Competitiveness, According to PwC’s Cities of Opportunity 7
play read on


Our Free eJournals
GlobalAutoExperts

To visit GlobalAutoExperts Directory, click here.


©2008 GlobalAutoIndustry.com | HCI Group, Ltd.
101 West Big Beaver Road, Suite 1400 | Troy, MI 48084 USA
USA Tel: +1.248.687.1060 | USA Fax: +1.248.927.0347
Fax UK: +44.(0)845.127.4765 | Fax Europe: +31.20.524.1659 | Fax Asia: +852.3015.8120